AX Consulting

Just another WordPress.com site

AX 2009 Misc Charges

Almost all of implementations have the Misc charges and Auto misc charges used in the AR and AP. Recently , I noticed a strange behaviour when i was using this feature in one of the implementation. This is related to the Misc charges with category “Percent”. We will take an example of Misc charge on a purchase transaction to understand the issue

Consider that there is an item on which  a 5 % duty is applicable on the net amount of the purchase. Therefore, consultants would like to utilize the ‘Auto misc charges’ feature for mapping this business requirement.

Let’s first create a Misc charge code e.g. “Duty’ as shown in the following screen shot:

clip_image001[5]

The Misc charge has been created with the following posting setup:

clip_image002[6]

i.e. the cost of the misc charge is to be loaded on the inventory value and offset to a Misc charge suspense account.

You may also notice that the Company currency is USD in the environment in which this simulation is being done. Consider that a Purchase order is raised in EUR on a vendor

clip_image003[6]

Att this stage , if the Duty was configured in the Auto misc charges then it would flow on the lines else we can manually configure a misc charge for the purchase lines that duty of 5% payable in USD ( as we are buying from an overseas vendor in EUR but would pay ‘duty” to customs in USD) . The sales line misc charge would be as follows

clip_image004[4]

Now , when we invoice update the purchase order and see the voucher of the invoice posting

clip_image005[4]

The misc charge amount got calculated 5% of EUR 10,000 as USD 500.  Therefore for those consultants/users who rightly disagree with this logic of calculation , the setup and configuration should be done with the above in mind.

To understand the effect for comparison purpose consider that the same item is bought from a vendor in India and the order is placed in INR. The exchange rate conversion for INR is 1 EUR = INR 80 . Therefore the Purchase order is placed for 5000*80 = INR 400,000.00 . The purchase line is also having the 5% duty as a misc charge .

Follow the steps for processing purchase order and invoice it . Check the invoice and the voucher:

Pls notice that this time the duty paid is USD 2000.00 as against the previous example of USD 500.00 (even that was not correct) .

Can one believe that for the same value of the item in the company currency just by changing the currency of the purchase order we could have ended up paying 4 time the cost of the item as duty?

Apparently Microsoft’s development team is working on this bug and we may hear some fix on the above.

Imparted from Here

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: